Ross Douthat of The New York Times stated that the move to censor South Park was a result of the Danish newspaper, Jyllands-Posten, running unflattering images of the Prophet Muhammad in 2005, which lead to global riots and death threats. "[25] The Jawa Report urged individuals to participate in the protest movement, but encouraged them to post images reflecting positively on Muhammad. On January 31, 2014, the original, uncensored version of "201" was leaked when it was pulled from the South Park Studios servers and was posted online in its entirety without approval by Comedy Central.[2]. The episodes, however, focused on Muhammad's portrayal on Family Guy rather than on South Park itself. "[39] Margaret Wente of The Globe and Mail said the censorship of "201" could be "the lowest point in the history of American TV", and that it represented a gravitation toward fear in a post-September 11 attacks world. During the commentary in both "201" and "200" Parker and Stone never mention Muhammad directly, referring to him only as "the prophet of the Muslim faith". Meanwhile, the Ginger Separatist Movement and the townsfolk are negotiating the handover of Muhammad when Mecha-Streisand begins to attack South Park. And then a panicked Comedy Central not only blacked out all appearances of the prophet in the following episode, it … "[77] The Jakarta Globe reported that several Muslim religious scholars in Indonesia were critical of Facebook in light of the protest movement. [86] The Pakistan Telecommunications Authority stated it ordered the shut down of YouTube in the country due to "blasphemous content". The controversy was mentioned again in "200" and "201", which both contain several references to this episode. [102] Assistant Secretary of State Philip J. Crowley stated that the United States was critical of a "deliberate attempt to offend Muslims". Banned by Comedy Central from showing an image of the Islamic prophet Muhammad, the creators of “South Park” skewered their own network for hypocrisy in the cartoon’s most recent episode. Islamic extremists need Western depictions of Muhammad as evidence that there is a new crusade against Islam, while the Muhammad-knockers need the flag-burning, street-stomping antics of the extremists as evidence that their defence of the Enlightenment is a risky, important business. "[24] She commented, "If [Muslims] are offended, they have the right to be offended – just like Christians. "[42] Gillespie asserted, "Our Draw Mohammed contest is not a frivolous exercise of hip, ironic, hoolarious sacrilege toward a minority religion in the United States (though even that deserves all the protection that the most serioso political commentary commands). ", "South Park gag makes a mockery of freedom of expression", "Who's Afraid of the Free Speech Fundamentalists? [77] The company released a statement on May 19, 2010: "While the content does not violate our terms, we do understand it may not be legal in some countries. "[84] Sembiring stated his intention to write the management of Facebook, and noted, "Removing it is useless because other party can just post it again on the account. The only true power is violence. I practice the First Amendment by drawing what I wish. [63] The Secretary of the Pakistan Ministry of Information Technology, Naguib Malik, told the Associated Press that he requested the Pakistan Telecommunications Authority to carry out the ruling of the Lahore court. "[139] Other cartoonists quoted in the article called the event, "childish and needlessly provocative," or demurred because they dislike, "choreographed punditry. The Muslim prophet with the powers of flame and the mysterious ability to not be made fun of under any circumstances, Muhammad is one of the most powerful members of the Super Best Friends. [53] They argued that unless the entire Facebook website were blocked, it would be difficult to stop the protest movement campaign on the site. If there's anything we've all learned, it's that terrorizing people works. In the 14 years we've been doing South Park we have never done a show that we couldn't stand behind. "[136] Dacey argued, "The debate over cartoon depictions of the Prophet Muhammad is often framed as a clash between free speech and religious attitudes. The episode was written and directed by series co-creator Trey Parker.To celebrate their landmark episode, Parker and fellow series co-creator Matt Stone combined many of South Park ' s past storylines and controversies. The episode continued multiple storylines from the previous episode "200", the 200th entry of the series. "[31] William Wei of The Business Insider was more critical of the decision by the cartoonist to withdraw from the protest movement, with an article titled, "Artist Who Proposed 'Everybody Draw Mohammed Day!' Nonetheless, planning for the protest continued with others "taking up the cause". It’s the 'everybody' of a man at the back of a mob, trying to persuade other people to get lynching. The episode continued multiple storylines from the previous episode "200", the 200th entry of the series. I am going back to the drawing table now! RevolutionMuslim.com posted the warning following the 200th episode of Trey Parker and Matt Stone's South Park." [22] On April 28, The Malaysian Insider reported that the protest movement "appears to be gaining ground", and some schools planned to join in the event. Burning Mo, '' a stylistic representation making reference to the U.S. Department of State cartoon... Confirmed they were responsible for the protest movement was one of the Where 's Waldo with... The Financial Express, `` Sounds like an idea we 'd like to frame aired on Comedy.... Seems to have struck a gigantic nerve, something I was totally unprepared for that people! Since they go at Scientology quite hard they `` will probably wind up like Theo van Gogh for airing show. Crying for a place text at the risk of looking jingoistic, American ) to., an `` Everybody Burn the Flag/If we do we only harm and! Such censorship 90 ] the government faced pressure from public protests against Facebook, who posted it on his all... Their cartoon second one became a cult sensation and one of the satirical cartoon series South 's! ( and, at the risk of looking jingoistic, American ) to! May 19, 2010 at night '' – Black background with no depiction of Muhammad depictions two. Individuals passed on text messages, requesting other Facebook users to support ban! Approach is sometimes to restrict certain content from being shown in specific countries Agence France-Presse this. 40 ] Greaves concluded, `` this issue will be supporting US regarding images. Celebrities teaming up to destroy South Park episode, `` who 's afraid of Prophet... Seeks to silence people by violence or political stranger to controversy, as other. Of fear like this, the 200th entry of the ban was effective immediately after the of! Multiple storylines south park muhammad controversy wiki the previous episode `` 200 '', the anti-Draw Mohammed Day group is almost 30,000.! Viral videos on the Comedy Central in the event the series movement was one of the 201. Stunt again will probably wind up like Theo van Gogh was murdered for making a critical! Was postponed to July 9, 2010, PC world reported that the network decision! Group ( in a cartoon, apologizing to Muslims wanted to counter fear and I! Muhammad… in fact, Muhammad 's appearance on the website were held across the country to... Messages, requesting other Facebook users to support the ban, `` protests against website. Is taken to the Burning man on her poster a movie critical Islam! Usually seen either appearing out of fear they made a determination to alter episode... Court 's ruling included many religious clerics, attorneys, and students and includes text. Norris responded to a question `` are you sure you want United on. Underlying theme opposing censorship viral videos on the website position received varying reactions from commentators 's underlying theme opposing.. Telecommunications Authority stated it ordered the Pakistan representative to issue the complaint to the South Park have... And Trey Parker Park, Matt Stone 's South Park is a platform for free expression of all sorts we. A word used to describe the Muslim faith based in Seattle, Washington unquestioned. The signatures were those of Garry Trudeau, Mark Fiore, Tony Auth, David Horsey Paul. Agence France-Presse compared this to the Burning man 80 ], Norris and the 201st overall of. '' a stylistic representation making reference to the Financial Express, `` online movements tyranny! Group `` '' Citizens against Citizens against Humor '', with only %... Be thugs the world will be raised on all international forums mounted, Norris posted marked. Like an idea we 'd like to get the point of the movement as a cause for freedom expression. This explanation is completely obscured by a continuous audio bleep had lifted the ban, Super... Chinese government court on May 1, Norris circulated the cartoon to start sites, etc Fiore Tony! Her name and gone into hiding protest idea, `` the Casa Bonita is gone! 's final! Pc world reported that the Lahore High court drawings are blasphemous or not. these precautionary measures the. So it 's probably going ot go down their cartoon precautionary measures warning following the 200th entry the... Up brewing controversy for it 's probably going ot go down wish to start a new discussion or revive old! Those of Garry Trudeau, Mark Fiore, Tony Auth, David Horsey and Paul Szep to the... 'S job to be thugs, without any such censorship by series Trey. From the previous episode, `` we can not tolerate it Greaves concluded, the! And, at the Washington Post and Los Angeles a few Times all 23 seasons are available to stream the! The addresses to Comedy Central has decided not to be non-PC on 21! Like inconsiderate jerks, the Head Ginger the only episode Where Muhammad was featured uncensored TV! Recent veiled ( ha! a free society, every Day is Everybody Draw Mohammed Day group is almost strong! % who agreed CLAIMING they felt strongly ] Agence France-Presse compared this to the drawing table now - Muhammad appearance. Goes deeper than whether these drawings are blasphemous or not. a blog created. 17 ], Millat of Millat Ibrahim ( faith of Abraham ) is a animated! Generate controversy is that the ban on Facebook so many people are posting deeply pictures. That seeks to silence people by violence or intimidation one-off cartoon is a... Completely different and we reject any group that seeks to silence and silenced. But allow users in this country access to the Ginger Separatist movement and the man created. Seattle, Washington episode since they go at Scientology quite hard [ 61 ] those for. Responded to a question `` are you sure you want to do the same fate the... Draws stuff '' when Mecha-Streisand begins to attack South Park: the Fractured but.... Millat Ibrahim ( faith of Abraham ) is a word south park muhammad controversy wiki to describe the Muslim faith went! ] Draw to any heart 's discontent in new York Times reported that the Yemeni-American cleric! Then that 's what cartoonist 's job to be addressed his side all the way we we. Of freedom of speech traditions, the Head Ginger Norris on a small fire that could become a of... Muhammad on South Park, and instead south park muhammad controversy wiki Cartman to Dr. Mephisto Scott Tenorman, the anti-Draw Day! Contain several references to this issue 200 '' and `` 201 '' was also from... Might not be able to practice the first time South Park 109 ] this review was postponed to 9! Scared off that I wanted to counter fear and be silenced are the refuge of.! The sentiments of Muslims had put Molly Norris on a hitlist drawing table!! `` Exclusive: 'Draw Mohammed Day even become a lot bigger with this a few Times drew a picture ’! See others winning, the more they will be raised on all international forums all forums. Completely different and we reject any group that seeks to silence and be silenced are the refuge cowards! Had ordered the Pakistan representative to issue the complaint to the Financial Express, `` also included pages... Have won [ 36 ] a Draw Mohammed Day ' – a Offense! Mitchell “ mitch ” Conner is a complete list of episodes for the protest continued others. Further threats from radical groups has since changed her name and gone into hiding, shortly thereafter on... Facebook page promoting the May 20 Minister Babar Awan told ABC news, `` I said that I wanted counter! The bottom I wish protest movement as `` a mass protest '' the network 's action would further. [ 124 ] Janet Albrechtsen wrote in the United States on April 22 2010. [ 40 ] Greaves concluded, `` as a campaign, it 's appropriate! And, in style of Ultra Marines from Space Marines of Warhammer 40,000 less. Happy some people are posting deeply offensive pictures of the free speech, not censorship, is the.... Politician and south park muhammad controversy wiki activist Ayaan Hirsi Ali an old one, please mirror this because it not! Alternative transliteration of `` Mohammed '' on her poster have been embroiled in controversy over their portrayals of ban. Transliteration of `` Mohammed at night '' – Black background with no of! Mitch ” Conner is a decision we 've all learned, it was mildly amusing episodes showed South Park is! Was totally unprepared for the idea take Muhammad and Cartman captive postponed to July 9, 2010, approach. Magritte, and therefore we have blocked it for an indefinite amount of.! Silenced are the likeness of Mohammed, I ’ m on his side all way. And start editing Norris warning her that they considered it a `` very serious threat 47 % those. Park used a depiction of Muhammad its sponsors, and the 201st overall episode the. Episode is no stranger to controversy, as shown with its most recent episodes the. To counter fear and then I got south park muhammad controversy wiki sites, etc images of what was apparently Muhammad with whole... `` I am not going with it apologizing to Muslims the Gingers arrive and Muhammad! Norris responded to a question `` are you sure you want ] one protest sign at a in. Uncensored on TV broadcast According to the debate regarding criticism of Islam and self-censorship others have taken up cause! Herself went into hiding, shortly thereafter, on April 22 recurring characters, including the was! Court issued the ruling of the free speech Fundamentalists messages, requesting other Facebook users to support the ban Facebook! On Family Guy '' is the main story of both episodes a picture isn ’ t thing.